John Guardiano at NewsRealBlog wrote a
follow-up on his previous blog post about Sarah Palin's support of Senator John McCain, in which he examined the reason cited in responses to his post (including mine): her loyalty. It led to the question as to how why loyalty to one man (John McCain) outweigh loyalty to her principles. The short answer to the question is this: Sarah
hasn't outweighed any one of her loyalties.
In an attempt to explain, I'll start off with pragmatism. Remembering what Ronald Reagan about the person you agree with 80% of the time, and considering the primary race in Arizona between John McCain and J.D. Hayworth, it leads to this question: Are they agreeable 80% of he time to be considered acceptable? Sarah believes both of them are, which leads to another factor, which is personal. To answer the title of Mr. Guardiano's post, Sarah is loyal to her conservative principles and her friends, which includes Senator McCain. She knows John McCain, she doesn't know J.D. Hayworth. Would you support somebody you don't know over somebody you regard as a friend, especially if both candidates are seen as acceptable candidates?
Furthermore, if J.D. Hayworth wins the primary election, Sarah has every intention of supporting Hayworth's bid in the general election. Does that sound like a betrayal of principles to you in any way, or an outweigh of loyalty to one man over loyalty to a set of conservative principles?
In the end, this debate doesn't matter for one important reason: when it comes to the Senate primary race in Arizona, she's in a damned if you do, damned if you don't situation (as a
commenter succinctly noted in response to Mr. Guardiano's previous post). Choosing McCain has resulted in criticism for supposedly betraying her principles, but choosing Hayworth would've resulted in criticism of throwing her friends under the bus for the sake of her principles. Even if she went neutral in this election, Sarah would still be criticized for her actions.
I repeat, Sarah Palin is loyal to both her principles as a common sense conservative and her friends. What she's been trying to do, in my opinion, is balance her loyalties. Whether she has or hasn't been successful is for you to decide. I expect you know what I think.